Orange Creamsicle Shake

This Orange Creamsicle Shake is creamy, smooth, and the Orange Julius Copycat recipe! Made with frozen orange juice, ice cream, whole milk, and a touch of vanilla, it’s the orange cream shake.

If you ever find yourself craving a creamy orange shake, this is the recipe you have been waiting for! The classic flavor combo is going to take you back to your teenage years when you were in the mall and grabbed an Orange Julius!

Don’t miss out on trying some of our other treats, such as our Galaxy ice creamviral fried chicken ice cream or this no-churn pistachio ice cream.

What stands out

• Lots of yummy orange flavor
• Simple ingredients
• Adult approved
• Kids love this easy milkshake recipe
• Great dessert for entertaining

Ingredients Needed For An Orange Milkshake

• Ice Cream
• Orange Juice Concentrate
• Vanilla Extract
• Milk or Heavy Cream

How To Make An Orange Julius Copycat

Step 1: Add ingredients to blender

Place ice cream in the blender. Pour in milk, orange juice concentrate, and vanilla.

Step 2: Blend

Blend until creamy, and there aren’t any lumps. Pour into a glass and garnish with some whipped cream and an orange slice. Enjoy!

Variations

1. Tropical Twist:
   • Use pineapple juice or a blend of pineapple and orange juice for a more tropical flavor.
   • Add a ripe banana for extra creaminess and a hint of banana flavor.
2. Citrus Medley:
   • Combine orange juice with other citrus juices like grapefruit, lemon, and lime for a tangy, citrus-packed smoothie.
3. Creamsicle Float:
   • Instead of blending, scoop the ice cream into a glass and pour the mixed juices over it for a classic creamsicle float.
4. Healthy Spin:
   • Substitute Greek yogurt for ice cream for a healthier, protein-rich version.
   • Add a handful of spinach or kale for added nutrients without altering the taste significantly.
5. Spiced Orange Smoothie:
   • Add a pinch of cinnamon or a dash of nutmeg for a spiced twist.
   • Top with a sprinkle of cinnamon or grated orange zest for extra flavor.

Tips & Tricks

1. Use Fresh Ingredients: Whenever possible, use fresh oranges and squeeze your own orange juice. It will taste fresher and more vibrant.
2. Adjust Sweetness: Taste the smoothie before pouring and adjust the sweetness by adding a bit of honey, agave syrup, or maple syrup if needed.
3. Ice Variation: For an even colder and thicker smoothie, use crushed ice or freeze the orange juice into ice cubes before blending.
4. Dairy Options: You can use milk or cream, but consider using alternatives like almond milk, coconut milk, or oat milk for a different flavor profile.
5. Add Texture: For added texture and crunch, throw in a handful of crushed graham crackers or granola and blend briefly.
6. Protein Boost: Incorporate a scoop of your usual protein powder to make this smoothie a more substantial meal replacement.
7. Zesty Garnish: Garnish with a twist of orange or lime zest for an extra burst of citrus aroma.
8. Serve Chilled: Make sure your ingredients are well-chilled before blending. You can also chill the glasses in the freezer for an extra frosty presentation.
9. Experiment: Feel free to experiment with other ingredients like a splash of vanilla-flavored vodka or rum for an adult version.
10. Customize Serving Glasses: Try serving the smoothie in chilled mason jars or glasses with colorful straws for a fun and summery presentation.

Practical notes

Do we have to use frozen orange juice?

To achieve the proper texture for the orange creamsicle shake, you need to use frozen orange juice concentrate. Additionally, frozen orange juice offers the best flavor.

Can we use flavored ice cream?

Yes, it’s fine to swap the vanilla ice cream. You could use strawberry or other fruit-flavored ice cream for a fun twist. Another option would be to use orange sherbet to get a strong orange flavor.

How can we make the orange creamsicle milkshake sweeter?

This drink has a vanilla shake base that is already quite sweet. Then, when you add the OJ, it becomes even sweeter. However, if you prefer even more sweetness, feel free to add 1 tablespoon of maple syrup or honey. You can also add sugar if you want. We wouldn’t add more than a couple of tablespoons of added sugar, so it’s not overwhelming.

Can we use coconut milk?

Sure! Please note that when using coconut milk, it’s best to opt for a full-fat version. Also, the orange creamsicle shake will take on a tropical flavor.

More Desserts

• No Churn Pineapple Coconut Ice Cream
• S’mores Brownies
• Banana Pudding Walking Tacos
• Air Fryer Peaches
• Lemon Almond Cake

Ingredients

Makes 2 servings

• 4 scoops vanilla ice cream
• 1 can orange juice concentrate, frozen
• 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
• 1/2 cup milk, or heavy cream

Equipment

• Ninja Professional Countertop Blender

Method

1. Place ice cream in the blender. Pour in milk, orange juice concentrate, and vanilla.
2. Blend until creamy, and there aren’t any lumps. Pour into a glass and garnish with some whipped cream and an orange slice. Enjoy!